SunButter Honey Sunflower Seed Butter, 16 oz Nut-Free Spread with 5g Plant-Based Protein, Roasted Rich & Savory Flavor, Smooth Texture | Vegan & Kosher
Grocery & Gourmet Food - 产品分析报告
  • Benchmark ASIN
    B0G192CRHW
  • Marketplace
    US
  • Category ID
    16310101
  • Analyzed Products
  • Keyword
    sunflower seed butter, seed butter spread
  • Price Range
    -
  • Minimum Net Profit Margin
    10.00%
  • MOQ
    100
  • Est. Purchasing Cost
    ¥4.07estimated
  • Data Date
    2026-08-05
  • Your Budget (for new listing) (CNY)
    ¥500,000.00
Profitability Difficulty
Low
High Risk Due to Price Competition
Newly Released Counts (All Brands)
1
New Brand (0)
Old Brand (1)
Success rate (all brands)
0.00%
New Brand (0%)
Old Brand (0.00%)
Most products net profit margin range
-46.16% - -22.98%
Listing

Report summary from Keble AI Agent: Listing

这个市场不该进。 结论很明确:现在不是“有机会但难做”,而是已经进入明显的价格战和封闭竞争状态,既不适合大品牌扩张,也不适合小商家试错。

Recommended Products Features Direction
B08WKP127B
Why do customers choose it?
  • 棕色酱体配红色瓶盖,包装颜色与同类巧克力涂抹酱区分不强
  • 普通16盎司罐装圆柱形包装,属于公模/常见零售罐型
  • 无花生、坚果友好,主打葵花籽基底与巧克力口味,适合过敏人群替代花生酱
  • 主要面向对花生/坚果过敏、需要学校安全零食或素食替代涂抹酱的家庭
  • Sales
    Avg. price: $6.54|Latest price: $6.20|Approx. recent monthly revenue: $6,540.00 (1000 pcs)|Net profit margin: -43.40%
    B0G192CRHW
    Why do customers choose it?
  • 罐身为蜂蜜黄主视觉,配合棕色瓶盖,整体更偏“蜂蜜口味”识别。
  • 16 oz 常规罐装圆形玻璃/塑料罐,包装形态与同类花生酱/种子酱高度一致。
  • 蜂蜜调味、无坚果过敏原、植物蛋白,主打学校/家庭可替代花生酱的安全涂抹酱。
  • 主要面向对花生和坚果过敏、需要学校安全配餐的家庭与儿童场景。
  • Sales
    Avg. price: $6.79|Latest price: $6.20|Approx. recent monthly revenue: $6,790.00 (1000 pcs)|Net profit margin: -24.27%

    These products have successfully captured market share and are profitable. Their design and features are suggested for your investment, based on market competition, saturation, and demand.

    New Brands
    VS
    Old Brands
    0 new brands1 old brands
    0 brands have new listings1 brands have new listings
    0 new listings1 new listings
    0 succeeded
    0 succeeded
    0 failed
    1 failed

    Green indicates better success rate, red indicates poorer success rate. If you are a new brand, focus on the left side; if you are an old brand, focus on the right side.

    Old Brands

      How much did others invest?

      Collapse
    • #Budget Requirement

      Listing

      不能进入。这个市场是明显的价格战区,而且已经过热:样本里可识别利润的产品盈利率是0%,新上架产品盈利率也是0%,所有可见产品都在-10%以下利润区间,完全不符合“至少15%利润才算可接受”的门槛。

      从钱看,用户预算是50万CNY,按当前报告里新产品的建议启动预算约为11,943.77 USD,表面上是够的;但这只够前期备货、物流和投放,不包含长期研发、品牌和认证。更关键的是,市场里没有任何真正跑通的成功新产品可抄:可见的新产品B0G192CRHW,售价$6.79,月销约1000,月营收$6,790,但单品利润率是-24.27%,投入预算约11,943.77 USD,仍然亏钱。老牌SunButter的多个在售产品也都亏损,像B08WKP127B售价$6.54、月销1000、利润率-43.4%;B000VK84P2月销6000、月营收$37,740、利润率-48.58%;B001EB9JI8利润率-22.04%。这说明不是“没钱就做不成”,而是“加钱也很难赢”。

      对大品牌来说,也不值得进;对小商家来说,更不值得碰。 这个赛道没有看到能拿来做标杆的真实小商家成功案例,反而看到的是老品牌在用低价和强投放硬扛,但依旧亏损;B0G192CRHW是唯一可见的新发售样本,却仍然亏。你如果一定要找参考,只能把SunButter当作“要避开的反面案例”,而不是模仿对象;小商家没有可复制的正面样本,大品牌也看不到可观的利润空间和差异化护城河。结论很直接:不要进入。

      Early sourcing + logistics + marketing budget (USD)
      $11,943.77 - $11,943.77
      Explains the budget

      With all these investments, who has profitable new releases

      How many new listings are released by old brands?
      100.00%
      New listing success rate (old brands):
      0.00%
      Alternatives
      1. 花生酱替代型涂抹酱(如普通品牌花生酱)
      2. 葵花籽仁/南瓜籽混合酱(自制或小众品牌)
      3. 芝麻酱/芝麻糊型抹酱(更常见、通常更便宜)
      4. 香蕉泥+少量蜂蜜的吐司涂抹方案(适合早餐场景)
      5. 奶酪抹酱或奶油奶酪(若不需要无过敏配方)
      6. 燕麦+酸奶的即食抹涂/蘸食替代方案
      7. 超市自有品牌的无坚果涂抹酱(通常价格更低、购买更容易)

      Alternative solutions may pose a risk to your investment in certain markets.

    • #Brands Investment Analysis

      Listing

      这个市场不适合进入,结论很明确:SunButter 这类玩法已经是老牌强势盘,且新切入也打不出利润,属于高成本、低回报的竞争场。现有数据里,品牌层面可识别利润产品占比是 0%,新产品盈利率也是 0%;你给我的预算 50 万 CNY 即使足够覆盖单个 ASIN 的前期投入,也只能进入一个已经失去利润空间的赛道。

      SunButter
      Old brand with the most profitable new products
      SunButter Seed Butter, 16 oz Nut-Free Spread with 7g Plant-Based Protein, Roasted Rich & Savory Flavor, Smooth Texture | Vegan, Kosher & Non-GMO
      Recent Monthly Revenue (USD):-(-)
      B0FC5ML2WSBrand is an old entry in this market
      Old ReleaseInsufficient Sales to Meet MOQOld ReleaseNot enough sales volume to meet 100 MOQ
      SunButter Chocolate Sunflower Seed Butter, 16 oz Nut-Free Spread with 7g Plant-Based Protein, Roasted Rich & Savory Flavor, Smooth Texture | Vegan, Kosher & Non-GMO
      Recent Monthly Revenue (USD):$6,540.00(1000pcs/month)
      B08WKP127B (4.2/5 (1280 Reviews))Brand is an old entry in this market
      Old ReleaseSufficient Sales to Meet MOQOld ReleaseNet profit margin below 10.00%
      SunButter Honey Sunflower Seed Butter, 16 oz Nut-Free Spread with 5g Plant-Based Protein, Roasted Rich & Savory Flavor, Smooth Texture | Vegan & Kosher
      Recent Monthly Revenue (USD):$6,790.00(1000pcs/month)
      B0G192CRHW (4.6/5 (128 Reviews))Brand is an old entry in this market
      New Upgraded Version on Old ASINSufficient Sales to Meet MOQWhite HatNet profit margin below 10.00%
    • #Differentiations

      Unique productsCommon products
      SunButter Chocolate Sunflower Seed Butter, 16 oz Nut-Free Spread with 7g Plant-Based Protein, Roasted Rich & Savory Flavor, Smooth Texture | Vegan, Kosher & Non-GMO
      Differentiation:
      1. 巧克力口味,和其他原味/蜂蜜味差异最大
      2. 棕色酱体,视觉上最容易联想到巧克力涂抹酱
      3. 面向喜欢甜味、儿童和零食场景,点击吸引力强
      B08WKP127B (4.2/5 (1280 Reviews))Brand is an old entry in this market
      Old ReleaseSufficient Sales to Meet MOQOld ReleaseNet profit margin below 10.00%
      SunButter Honey Sunflower Seed Butter, 16 oz Nut-Free Spread with 5g Plant-Based Protein, Roasted Rich & Savory Flavor, Smooth Texture | Vegan & Kosher
      Differentiation:
      1. 蜂蜜黄包装最醒目,和其他棕色系产品区分明显
      2. 蜂蜜口味定位清晰,适合想要更甜、更温和口感的用户
      3. 无坚果卖点明确,适合过敏家庭和学校午餐场景
      B0G192CRHW (4.6/5 (128 Reviews))Brand is an old entry in this market
      New Upgraded Version on Old ASINSufficient Sales to Meet MOQWhite HatNet profit margin below 10.00%
    • What net profit margin are others making?

      Collapse
    • #Net Profit Margins: All vs New

      Listing

      这个市场不值得进入:新产品利润分布几乎全线亏损,属于高风险价格战市场。 现有可见的新产品里,盈利率数据直接显示 100% 都落在亏损区间,核心新 ASIN B0G192CRHW 也在亏损,说明现在进场不是拼产品,而是拼资金和补贴能力。

      Profitability difficulty
      High Risk Due to Price Competition

      All products distribution on different profit levels

      All products profit ratio distribution, including all products. For products with insufficient sales or missing profit ratio data, they will be categorized into other rows. This distribution included products that cannot determine the release date.

      x < -10.0%
      -10.0% <= x < 0.0%
      0.0% <= x < 10.0%
      10.0% <= x < 20.0%
      20.0% <= x < 30.0%
      30.0% <= x < 40.0%
      x >= 40.0%
      other

      New products distribution on different profit levels

      This are the profit ratios of all new products. There are products without sufficient sales, no more than 100pcs in 3 months, or no profit ratio data, or just released. Those will be considered as 'other'

      x < -10.0%
      -10.0% <= x < 0.0%
      0.0% <= x < 10.0%
      10.0% <= x < 20.0%
      20.0% <= x < 30.0%
      30.0% <= x < 40.0%
      x >= 40.0%
      other
    • #Top Products by Net Profit Margin

      Top 20 Non-Profitable Products

      Products with negative profitability ranked by lowest profit value. Only includes products classified as non-profitable regardless of release date.

      B000VK84P2
      B000VK84P2
      SunButter
      2014-09-25
      No
      $6.29
      6000pcs
      $37740.0
      -48.58%
      $-18334.09
      B001EB9JI8
      B001EB9JI8
      SunButter
      2014-04-27
      No
      $6.84
      2000pcs
      $13680.0
      -22.04%
      $-3015.07
      B08WKP127B
      B08WKP127B
      SunButter
      2021-02-01
      No
      $6.54
      1000pcs
      $6540.0
      -43.4%
      $-2838.36
      B0G192CRHW
      B0G192CRHW
      SunButter
      2025-11-07
      No
      $6.79
      1000pcs
      $6790.0
      -24.27%
      $-1647.93
      B0FC5ML2WS
      B0FC5ML2WS
      SunButter
      2025-06-06
      No
      $-
      -pcs
      $-
      -%
      $-

      Top 20 Non-Profitable New Products

      New products with negative profitability ranked by lowest profit value. Only includes newly released products classified as non-profitable.

      B0G192CRHW
      B0G192CRHW
      SunButter
      2025-11-07
      No
      $6.79
      1000pcs
      $6790.0
      -24.27%
      $-1647.93
    • Is this a good time to enter the market?

      Collapse
    • #New Product Success Rates

      Listing

      这个市场不值得进入:利润率整体为0%,而新产品利润率也是0%,已经是典型的价格战/高风险市场。 现有数据里,老品牌 SunButter 作为成熟大品牌,5个可识别产品全部亏损,品牌成功率0%;新产品 B0G192CRHW 虽然有1000月销量、6790美元月营收,但利润率仍是-24.3%,说明不是“没需求”,而是“卖得动也不赚钱”。

      证据很直接:市场里可识别的盈利产品占比为0.00%,新发布产品盈利率也是0.00%;这已经不是可优化的问题,而是竞争结构有问题。 代表性失败案例 B0G192CRHW(SunButter)早期投入约11,943.77美元,但最近月利润为-1,647.93美元,最新价6.79美元仍扛不住物流、FBA和采购成本;同品牌老款 B08WKP127B 月销1000、营收6540美元,利润率-43.4%,B000VK84P2 月销6000、营收37740美元,利润仍为-18,334.09美元。时间趋势上,2025年只出现了新产品但全部亏损,2022-2024没有看到正向新产品释放,说明市场不是成长,而是被老玩家和低价竞争压住了。对新品牌更不友好:当前能看到的“成功”并不是真正新品牌成功,而是老品牌在做新释放但依然亏损;没有看到<300评价的真实小品牌成功案例,反而有 1280、6366 这类高评价老产品,更像强势品牌或重营销产品,不适合把它当作小商家胜利样本。

      New products success rate.

      What is the ratio of profitable products

      Profitable (Unidentifiable released date)
      Profitable (Old product)
      Profitable (New product)
      Profitable (New product on old listing)
      New products but non profitable
      No data available

      Nonprofitable new products divide by brands

      What is the ratio of different brands owning all nonprofitable new products

      SunButter
    • #Success Rate by Entry Time

      Listing

      这个市场不值得进入,已经是价格战高风险区,且没有新的可复制成功样本。 近几年新品进入几乎停滞,2025年全年只有 SunButter 的 B0G192CRHW 这一条新产品记录,而且它是非盈利;市场整体可识别的盈利产品占比为 0.00%,新品盈利率也是 0.00%,说明不是“少数人吃肉”,而是几乎没人能稳定赚到钱。

      证据非常直接:市场已经被老品牌锁死。 在新产品里,SunButter 这一个老品牌同时占据了 100.00% 的非盈利样本;旧品牌发布的新产品盈利率为 0%,非盈利率为 100.00%。产品层面看,B000VK84P2、B001EB9JI8、B08WKP127B、B0FC5ML2WS、B0G192CRHW 这些样本都被标记为“不盈利”,共同原因是低利润率、同质化强、竞争极端激烈;其中 B000VK84P2 月营收 37,740 美元但仍不赚钱,B001EB9JI8 为 13,680 美元,B08WKP127B 为 6,540 美元,B0G192CRHW 的市场进入预算约 11,943.77 美元,但依然失败。市场入场趋势也很差:2022–2024 年几乎没有新产品释放,2025 年只出现 1 个样本,说明不是增长市场,而是已经萎缩/封闭的市场。

      结论:大品牌和小商家都不该进;如果硬进,大品牌也要重投入但回报不确定,小商家更不可能靠正常打法成功。 这个市场不满足你要求的“可复制的小商家成功案例”,也没有低于 300 评价的真实小商家成功样本可作为参考;相反,当前成功逻辑更像是品牌历史和资源堆出来的存量优势,而不是新品创新。关键点只有一句:不要进入。

      How many products released each year

      Y-axis is product counts. X-axis is time period. For each time period, there are 2 column, each column is a released type of a product. Columns are in following orders: New product, New product on old listing

      How many products released each month

      Y-axis is product counts. X-axis is time period. For each time period, there are 2 column, each column is a released type of a product. Columns are in following orders: New product, New product on old listing

    • #Net Profit Margins by Entry Time

      Different profit ratios of products released in year

      Header is the profit ratios and first column is different time period. Each cells includes how many products are relased at the specific timerange and has a corresponding profit ratios. Only profitable and with active sales (more than 100 pcs in 3 months) will be considered. Any products without sufficient sold units in 3 months will be marked as 'other'.

      Time/Profit%x < -10.0%-10.0% <= x < 0.0%0.0% <= x < 10.0%10.0% <= x < 20.0%20.0% <= x < 30.0%30.0% <= x < 40.0%x >= 40.0%other
      202200000000
      202300000000
      202400000000
      202510000000
      202600000000
      ≥ 10% Profitable
      < 10% Unprofitable
      Unidentifiable

      Different profit ratios of products released in month

      Header is the profit ratios and first column is different time period. Each cells includes how many products are relased at the specific timerange and has a corresponding profit ratios. Only profitable and with active sales (more than 100 pcs in 3 months) will be considered. Any products without sufficient sold units in 3 months will be marked as 'other'.

      Time/Profit%x < -10.0%-10.0% <= x < 0.0%0.0% <= x < 10.0%10.0% <= x < 20.0%20.0% <= x < 30.0%30.0% <= x < 40.0%x >= 40.0%other
      2025/800000000
      2025/900000000
      2025/1000000000
      2025/1110000000
      2025/1200000000
      2026/100000000
      2026/200000000
      2026/300000000
      2026/400000000
      2026/500000000
      2026/600000000
      2026/700000000
      ≥ 10% Profitable
      < 10% Unprofitable
      Unidentifiable
    • What factors contribute to success or failure?

      Collapse
    • #Case Study

      Success Cases
    What is Keble?

    Keble is an e-commerce AI Agent that helps sellers solve daily e-commerce issues. This report is generated by Keble AI.

    Analyze Product Opportunity with Keble
    1. One report to tell you whether to enter the market or not, significantly reducing inventory risk.
    Keble AI Agent