Criusia Over the Door Shoe Organizer, 20-30 Pairs Heavy-Duty Hanging Shoe Storage with Large Pockets, 10-Tier Door Shoe Rack with 4 Hooks for Sneakers Sandals Heels Boots (Black)
Over the Door Shoe Organizers - 产品分析报告
  • Benchmark ASIN
    B0GS8ZYY5V
  • Marketplace
    US
  • Category ID
    11601917011
  • Analyzed Products
  • Keyword
    under sink organizer, cabinet shelf organizer
  • Price Range
    -
  • Minimum Net Profit Margin
    10.00%
  • MOQ
    100
  • Est. Purchasing Cost
    ¥21.51estimated
  • Data Date
    2026-08-01
  • Your Budget (for new listing) (CNY)
    ¥500,000.00
Profitability Difficulty
Low
High Risk Due to Price Competition
Newly Released Counts (All Brands)
14
New Brand (14)
Old Brand (0)
Success rate (all brands)
7.14%
New Brand (7.14%)
Old Brand (0%)
Most products net profit margin range
-8.74% - 12.68%
Listing

Report summary from Keble AI Agent: Listing

结论很明确:这个市场不值得进入,已经进入明显的价格战高风险区,新品牌成功率只有7.14%,低于你要求的10%警戒线。 现有数据里,新进入的品牌只有13个,但真正跑通的只有 Criusia;而且最近一批新品牌几乎都没转化成可盈利产品,说明这不是“还有空间”,而是“少数样本偶发成功,多数新进入者亏损”。

证据一:竞争和利润都在恶化。 可识别的新上架产品里,盈利率只有8.33%,新品牌新品盈利率只有7.14%,非盈利产品占91.67%;利润区间也很差,市场新产品利润率范围只有 -8.74% 到 12.68%,说明大部分产品都压在低利润甚至亏损边缘。按时间看,2025 年到 2026 年上半年新上架几乎没有形成稳定盈利面,最近月份也没有出现利润明显改善,反而是持续被同质化和价格压制。品牌层面,Criusia 的 B0GS8ZYY5V 是唯一明确盈利的新品牌新品,售价 35.85 美元,利润率 16.19%,月销 800,月营收 28,680 美元,前期识别预算 14,828.91 美元;但它的另一个新款 B0H3N6QY7Z 已经失败,说明这条路不是复制一个外形就能赢。反过来,HIKATAB 的 B0FF4WTQK6 和 B0FF4ZCW9R 利润率只有 8.7% 和 7.74%,月销仅 50,属于低利润挤压样本;Generic 的 B0G234BZ3Q 虽然标价 33.99 美元,利润率也只有 11.77%,但没有形成有效销量,更说明同类款很难跑通。

Recommended Products Features Direction
B0GS8ZYY5V
Why do customers choose it?
  • 黑色软织纹理外观,偏现代极简风
  • 10层超大容量挂门鞋架,双侧附加6个收纳口袋
  • 除鞋子外,还增加两侧大口袋,能收纳腰带、毛巾、袜子等小物,提升单品复用性
  • 宿舍、RV、以及小空间家庭用户,尤其是需要门后立体收纳且兼顾零碎小物整理的人群
  • Sales
    Avg. price: $35.85|Latest price: $35.99|Approx. recent monthly revenue: $28,680.00 (800 pcs)|Net profit margin: 16.19%
    B0DN6BGZ6N
    Why do customers choose it?
  • 白色极简款,视觉更干净,适合浅色柜体
  • 16.5-31.5英寸可伸缩结构,且为2件装的抽屉/柜板下悬挂式鞋架
  • 可伸缩长度适配不同柜体,利用柜板下方垂直空间;可横向扩展并支持叠放以提升收纳密度
  • 适合小户型、宿舍、入口玄关和需要提升柜内空间利用率的收纳用户
  • Sales
    Avg. price: $29.99|Latest price: $29.99|Approx. recent monthly revenue: $1,499.50 (50 pcs)|Net profit margin: 13.63%

    These products have successfully captured market share and are profitable. Their design and features are suggested for your investment, based on market competition, saturation, and demand.

    New Brands
    VS
    Old Brands
    13 new brands7 old brands
    13 brands have new listings0 brands have new listings
    14 new listings0 new listings
    1 succeeded
    0 succeeded
    11 failed
    0 failed

    Green indicates better success rate, red indicates poorer success rate. If you are a new brand, focus on the left side; if you are an old brand, focus on the right side.

    New Brands
    ...
    Old Brands
    ...

      How much did others invest?

      Collapse
    • #Budget Requirement

      Listing

      不建议进入,这个市场已经明显偏饱和,而且是价格战高风险区。 用户预算 50万人民币虽然能覆盖部分单个ASIN前期投入,但对长期研发、品牌和认证并不宽裕;按当前样本看,市场里可识别盈利产品只有 9.52%,新品牌新发产品盈利率只有 7.14%,低于你要求的 10% 高风险线,说明新进入者大概率先亏后难翻身。

      Early sourcing + logistics + marketing budget (USD)
      $14,828.91 - $14,828.91
      Explains the budget

      With all these investments, who has profitable new releases

      How many new listings are released by old brands?
      0.00%
      New listing success rate (new brands):
      7.14%
      Which new brands have these successful new listings?
      Alternatives
      1. 橱柜门后/壁挂式分层收纳袋(可替代部分上门鞋架功能,价格通常更低,安装也更简单)
      2. 可调节层板下挂篮/夹层收纳篮(利用现有柜板空间,不用单独占地,适合临时和租房场景)
      3. 免打孔粘贴式收纳篮/收纳架(适合轻量物品,改造门下或柜内空间,门槛低)
      4. 可堆叠塑料收纳箱/鞋盒(通用性强,购买门槛低,既能收纳鞋也能收纳杂物)
      5. 张力杆+布艺悬挂收纳袋(无需工具、可快速装拆,适合门后和小空间)
      6. 简易金属层架/置物架(比专用鞋柜更通用,日后可转作厨房、浴室或杂物收纳)
      7. 抽屉式收纳盒或鞋托架(适合把鞋放进柜内,成本低,且对空间高度要求更灵活)

      Alternative solutions may pose a risk to your investment in certain markets.

    • #Brands Investment Analysis

      Listing

      这个市场不值得进入,已经出现明显的饱和和价格战信号。 采样里可见的新品牌成功率只有7.14%,而市场整体可识别盈利率只有9.52%;更关键的是,新品牌新上架产品里非盈利占比高达78.57%,这说明新进入者大多在亏钱,靠低价和高投入硬拼的风险很高。

      从证据看,Criusia 是唯一能拿来做“成立样本”的新品牌:ASIN B0GS8ZYY5V,定价35.85美元,利润率16.2%,月销800,月营收28,680美元,前期可识别预算14,828.91美元,首三个月平均销量200,属于有真实跑通的白帽新品牌案例。它的成功点很清楚:在原有门后鞋架基础上做了功能差异化,加入两侧大口袋,外观也更现代极简;但它的起步投入已经不低,且后续还出现了同品牌新ASIN B0H3N6QY7Z直接失败,说明这个细分里并不是“做一个类似款就能赢”。老品牌 HIKATAB 也能说明门槛:ASIN B0FF4WTQK6 和 B0FF4ZCW9R 的利润率分别只有8.7%和7.74%,40条左右评价、月销50,已经低于可盈利线,属于典型挤压型竞争样本;Generic 的 B0G234BZ3Q 也停留在11.77%但没有形成有效销量,不构成可复制的成功。另一个更适合大品牌参考的成熟样本是 CroBlissful 的 B0DN6BGZ6N,43条评价、4.6分、月销50、价格29.99美元,靠可伸缩结构和柜板下空间利用做差异化,但它更像老牌资源型打法,不适合小品牌照搬。

      结论很直接:大品牌也不是好入场,除非愿意重投并做明显创新;小品牌更不应该进。 你现在的500000元预算虽然能覆盖单ASIN前期投入,但在这个市场里,成功并不只看首发预算,还要扛品牌、内容、测试和可能的认证成本。真正应该跟的案例只有 Criusia 的 B0GS8ZYY5V;应该避开的则是 HIKATAB 的 B0FF4WTQK6/B0FF4ZCW9R 和 Generic 的 B0G234BZ3Q 这类低利润、低销量、非盈利样本。

      Criusia
      Most investment in new productsLeast investment in new productsNew products with Highest revenue
      Criusia Over the Door Shoe Organizer, 20-30 Pairs Heavy-Duty Hanging Shoe Storage with Large Pockets, 10-Tier Door Shoe Rack with 4 Hooks for Sneakers Sandals Heels Boots (Black)
      Recent Monthly Revenue (USD):$28,680.00(800pcs/month)
      B0GS8ZYY5V (4.6/5 (32 Reviews))Brand is a new entry in this market
      New ReleaseSufficient Sales to Meet MOQWhite HatThis listing is deemed profitable
      HIKATAB
      Old brand with the most profitable new products
      HIKATAB Hanging Shoe Organizer for Closet, Expandable Rack Organizer Under Cabinet Shelf - for Kitchen, Book or Clothing Storage and Organization. (White-1Pcs)
      Recent Monthly Revenue (USD):$949.50(50pcs/month)
      B0FF4WTQK6 (3.4/5 (40 Reviews))Brand is an old entry in this market
      Old ReleaseInsufficient Sales to Meet MOQOld ReleaseNot enough sales volume to meet 100 MOQ
      HIKATAB Hanging Shoe Organizer for Closet, Expandable Rack Organizer Under Cabinet Shelf - for Kitchen, Book or Clothing Storage and Organization. (Black-1Pcs)
      Recent Monthly Revenue (USD):$949.50(50pcs/month)
      B0FF4ZCW9R (3.4/5 (40 Reviews))Brand is an old entry in this market
      Old ReleaseSufficient Sales to Meet MOQOld ReleaseNet profit margin below 10.00%
      Generic
      Least profitable new products
      Under-Shelf Expandable Shoe Rack Organizer, White Metal, 40-70cm Width Adjustable, Cabinet Storage for Closet,Retractable Shoe Rack Organizer,Expandable(3 Pcs)
      Recent Monthly Revenue (USD):-(-)
      B0G234BZ3Q (4.3/5 (11 Reviews))Brand is a new entry in this market
      New ReleaseInsufficient Sales to Meet MOQUnderperformingNot enough sales volume to meet 100 MOQ
    • #Differentiations

      Unique productsCommon products
      Criusia Over the Door Shoe Organizer, 20-30 Pairs Heavy-Duty Hanging Shoe Storage with Large Pockets, 10-Tier Door Shoe Rack with 4 Hooks for Sneakers Sandals Heels Boots (Black)
      Differentiation:
      1. 黑色软织纹理,现代极简风,视觉辨识度高
      2. 门后10层大容量,适合宿舍/RV/小空间
      3. 两侧加6个口袋,功能更丰富,容易吸引点击
      B0GS8ZYY5V (4.6/5 (32 Reviews))Brand is a new entry in this market
      New ReleaseSufficient Sales to Meet MOQWhite HatThis listing is deemed profitable
      CroBlissful 2 Pcs Expandable Shoe Rack Organizer for Closet 16.5-31.5 Inch Adjustable Retractable Hanging Cabinet Shoe Shelf Dorm Room Storage for Space Saving (White)
      Differentiation:
      1. 白色极简外观,和黑色门挂式鞋架差异明显
      2. 16.5-31.5英寸可伸缩,适配不同柜体
      3. 2件装可叠放,突出柜内分层收纳
      B0DN6BGZ6N (4.6/5 (43 Reviews))Brand is an old entry in this market
      Old ReleaseSufficient Sales to Meet MOQOld ReleaseThis listing is deemed profitable
    • What net profit margin are others making?

      Collapse
    • #Net Profit Margins: All vs New

      Listing

      这个市场不适合进入:新品牌新品几乎全军覆没,利润也被压到低位,已经是明显的价格战环境。 现有证据里,12个可判定新品只有1个赚钱,成功率只有8.33%;新品牌新品盈利率只有7.14%,非盈利率高达78.57%,已经低于你要求的10%高风险线,属于不应继续推进的市场。

      Profitability difficulty
      High Risk Due to Price Competition

      All products distribution on different profit levels

      All products profit ratio distribution, including all products. For products with insufficient sales or missing profit ratio data, they will be categorized into other rows. This distribution included products that cannot determine the release date.

      x < -10.0%
      -10.0% <= x < 0.0%
      0.0% <= x < 10.0%
      10.0% <= x < 20.0%
      20.0% <= x < 30.0%
      30.0% <= x < 40.0%
      x >= 40.0%
      other

      New products distribution on different profit levels

      This are the profit ratios of all new products. There are products without sufficient sales, no more than 100pcs in 3 months, or no profit ratio data, or just released. Those will be considered as 'other'

      x < -10.0%
      -10.0% <= x < 0.0%
      0.0% <= x < 10.0%
      10.0% <= x < 20.0%
      20.0% <= x < 30.0%
      30.0% <= x < 40.0%
      x >= 40.0%
      other
    • #Top Products by Net Profit Margin

      Top 20 Profitable Products

      Most profitable products ranked by profit value. Only includes products with positive profitability and active sales, regardless of release date.

      B0GS8ZYY5V
      B0GS8ZYY5V
      Criusia
      2026-06-10
      Yes
      $35.85
      800pcs
      $28680.0
      16.19%
      $4643.3
      B0DN6BGZ6N
      B0DN6BGZ6N
      CroBlissful
      2024-11-15
      Yes
      $29.99
      50pcs
      $1499.5
      13.63%
      $204.39

      Top 20 Profitable New Products

      Most profitable new products ranked by profit value. Only includes newly released products with positive profitability and active sales.

      B0GS8ZYY5V
      B0GS8ZYY5V
      Criusia
      2026-06-10
      Yes
      $35.85
      800pcs
      $28680.0
      16.19%
      $4643.3
    • Is this a good time to enter the market?

      Collapse
    • #New Product Success Rates

      Listing

      这个市场不适合进入,结论很明确:新品牌几乎没法靠正常打法赢,已经是高竞争、接近价格战的市场。 你给的样本里,新品盈利率只有8.33%,新品牌新品盈利率同样只有8.33%,整体可判定为高风险;而且可识别的盈利新品里,只有 Criusia 的 B0GS8ZYY5V 站住了,其他新品牌几乎全部失败,说明不是“机会分散”,而是“少数强者吃掉大部分机会”。

      证据非常集中:B0GS8ZYY5V(Criusia)是唯一真正跑通的新品牌新品,售价35.85美元,毛利率16.19%,月收入28680美元,单品预算14828.91美元;它的成功点是基于旧款做了功能差异和外观差异,增加了双侧收纳袋,面向宿舍、RV和小空间家庭。 反过来看,失败样本大量集中在 2025 年到 2026 年初,新品几乎全军覆没;例如 HIKATAB 的 B0FF4WTQK6 和 B0FF4ZCW9R 都只有7.74%~8.7%毛利率,Generic 的 B0G234BZ3Q 只有11.77%毛利率仍判定不盈利,说明市场已被低差异、通用款挤压得很厉害。更关键的是,市场里大多数产品利润分布都落在“other”,可识别的高利润产品极少,说明真正能赚钱的并不多。

      对小品牌来说,能“合法成功”的案例几乎只有 Criusia 这一类:不是纯新概念,而是站在旧款基础上做明显功能升级,而且还要有至少约14828.91美元的单ASIN启动预算;如果走普通同质化款,成功概率极低。 对大品牌来说也不是好消息,因为旧品牌样本里同样出现大量不赚钱产品,说明这不是“谁来都能做”的市场,而是已经进入强竞争阶段。短结论:不要进入;如果硬要做,只能复制 Criusia 这种“旧款改良 + 明显功能增量 + 更高预算”的打法,否则大概率亏。

      New products success rate.

      What is the ratio of profitable products

      Profitable (Unidentifiable released date)
      Profitable (Old product)
      Profitable (New product)
      Profitable (New product on old listing)
      New products but non profitable

      Profitable new products divide by brands

      What is the ratio of different brands owning all profitable new products

      Criusia

      Nonprofitable new products divide by brands

      What is the ratio of different brands owning all nonprofitable new products

      Other
    • #Success Rate by Entry Time

      Listing

      这个市场不值得进入,已经接近/进入过度拥挤状态,而且正在走向更激烈的价格战。 过去一年新入场几乎全军覆没:新品牌新产品成功率只有8.33%,整体可识别利润产品占比也只有9.52%,说明对新玩家非常不友好。

      How many products released each year

      Y-axis is product counts. X-axis is time period. For each time period, there are 2 column, each column is a released type of a product. Columns are in following orders: New product, New product on old listing

      How many products released each month

      Y-axis is product counts. X-axis is time period. For each time period, there are 2 column, each column is a released type of a product. Columns are in following orders: New product, New product on old listing

    • #Net Profit Margins by Entry Time

      Different profit ratios of products released in year

      Header is the profit ratios and first column is different time period. Each cells includes how many products are relased at the specific timerange and has a corresponding profit ratios. Only profitable and with active sales (more than 100 pcs in 3 months) will be considered. Any products without sufficient sold units in 3 months will be marked as 'other'.

      Time/Profit%x < -10.0%-10.0% <= x < 0.0%0.0% <= x < 10.0%10.0% <= x < 20.0%20.0% <= x < 30.0%30.0% <= x < 40.0%x >= 40.0%other
      202200000000
      202300000000
      202400000000
      202500000008
      202600010005
      ≥ 10% Profitable
      < 10% Unprofitable
      Unidentifiable

      Different profit ratios of products released in month

      Header is the profit ratios and first column is different time period. Each cells includes how many products are relased at the specific timerange and has a corresponding profit ratios. Only profitable and with active sales (more than 100 pcs in 3 months) will be considered. Any products without sufficient sold units in 3 months will be marked as 'other'.

      Time/Profit%x < -10.0%-10.0% <= x < 0.0%0.0% <= x < 10.0%10.0% <= x < 20.0%20.0% <= x < 30.0%30.0% <= x < 40.0%x >= 40.0%other
      2025/800000002
      2025/900000003
      2025/1000000000
      2025/1100000002
      2025/1200000001
      2026/100000001
      2026/200000000
      2026/300000001
      2026/400000000
      2026/500000000
      2026/600010001
      2026/700000002
      ≥ 10% Profitable
      < 10% Unprofitable
      Unidentifiable
    • What factors contribute to success or failure?

      Collapse
    • #Case Study

      Success Cases
      CroBlissful 2 Pcs Expandable Shoe Rack Organizer for Closet 16.5-31.5 Inch Adjustable Retractable Hanging Cabinet Shoe Shelf Dorm Room Storage for Space Saving (White)
      Price (USD)
      $29.99
      Released Type
      Old Release (2024-11-15)
      Brand is an old entry in this market
      Size and Weight
      42.2 x 16.7 x 6.1 cm, 1470.00g

      Profitable Factors

      Based on old ASINDistinct functions and features

      Design & Appearance

      白色极简款,视觉更干净,适合浅色柜体, 16.5-31.5英寸可伸缩结构,且为2件装的抽屉/柜板下悬挂式鞋架

      Key Buying Motive

      可伸缩长度适配不同柜体,利用柜板下方垂直空间;可横向扩展并支持叠放以提升收纳密度

      Target Customers

      适合小户型、宿舍、入口玄关和需要提升柜内空间利用率的收纳用户

      Early Investment

      Investment

      Monthly Revenue (Recent) (USD)
      $1,499.50
      50 sold in the past 30 days · as of 2026年8月

      Net Profit Margin

      Sea Freight
      9.37% / 13.63%
      Peak / Non Peak
      Rail Freight
      - / -
      Peak / Non Peak
      Air Freight
      -14.55% / -10.29%
      Peak / Non Peak

      Sales & BSR Performance

      Criusia Over the Door Shoe Organizer, 20-30 Pairs Heavy-Duty Hanging Shoe Storage with Large Pockets, 10-Tier Door Shoe Rack with 4 Hooks for Sneakers Sandals Heels Boots (Black)
      Price (USD)
      $35.85
      Released Type
      New Release (2026-06-10)
      Brand is a new entry in this market
      Size and Weight
      37.5 x 32.7 x 7.5 cm, 1048.00g

      Profitable Factors

      Based on old ASINDistinct functions and featuresUnique appearance design

      Design & Appearance

      黑色软织纹理外观,偏现代极简风, 10层超大容量挂门鞋架,双侧附加6个收纳口袋

      Key Buying Motive

      除鞋子外,还增加两侧大口袋,能收纳腰带、毛巾、袜子等小物,提升单品复用性

      Target Customers

      宿舍、RV、以及小空间家庭用户,尤其是需要门后立体收纳且兼顾零碎小物整理的人群

      Early Investment

      Investment

      Monthly Revenue (Recent) (USD)
      $28,680.00
      800 sold in the past 30 days · as of 2026年8月

      Net Profit Margin

      Sea Freight
      10.28% / 16.19%
      Peak / Non Peak
      Rail Freight
      - / -
      Peak / Non Peak
      Air Freight
      -10.59% / -4.68%
      Peak / Non Peak

      Sales & BSR Performance

    What is Keble?

    Keble is an e-commerce AI Agent that helps sellers solve daily e-commerce issues. This report is generated by Keble AI.

    Analyze Product Opportunity with Keble
    1. One report to tell you whether to enter the market or not, significantly reducing inventory risk.
    Keble AI Agent