3pack Dog Poop Bag Holder Dog Poop Bag Dispenser with Clip & Side Hook for Filled Poop Bags Pet Waste Bag Holder Built-in Rotating Shaft for Easy Bag Extraction for Dog Walking Hiking
Pet Supplies - 产品分析报告
  • Benchmark ASIN
    B0GVDTH1D7
  • Marketplace
    CA
  • Category ID
    6205514011
  • Analyzed Products
  • Keyword
    pet waste bag dispenser, dog poop bag holder, leash waste bag holder
  • Price Range
    -
  • Minimum Net Profit Margin
    10.00%
  • MOQ
    100
  • Est. Purchasing Cost
    No price data
  • Data Date
    2026-07-23
  • Your Budget (for new listing) (CNY)
    ¥500,000.00
Profitability Difficulty
Unknown
Unknown - Insufficient New Releases
Newly Released Counts (All Brands)
2
New Brand (2)
Old Brand (0)
Success rate (all brands)
0.00%
New Brand (0.00%)
Old Brand (0%)
Most products net profit margin range
-40.48% - 28.28%
Listing

Report summary from Keble AI Agent: Listing

这个市场不值得进入,结论很明确:已进入价格战和同质化阶段,小品牌和大品牌都不建议现在进。 现有数据里,新品牌只有2个,且新品牌新品盈利率是0%,全部新上架产品也都是亏损;更关键的是,近期开出的新产品没有任何盈利样本,说明不是“还差一点”,而是入口本身就被成本和竞争压死了。

Recommended Products Features Direction
B0H4V5CJJP
Why do customers choose it?
  • 外观为通用金属夹式宠物便便袋挂件,造型与竞品高度相似
  • 主打免手提便便袋、可夹在牵引绳/背包/钥匙扣上
  • 遛狗时需要临时解放双手的普通养宠人群
  • Sales
    Avg. price: C$9.99|Latest price: C$9.99|Approx. recent monthly revenue: - (- pcs)|Net profit margin: -10.33%
    B09WRDD5RH
    Why do customers choose it?
  • 绿色外观较醒目,但并非稀缺差异点
  • 造型为常见的硅胶挂扣式拾便袋收纳器,市场上同类很多
  • 主打可弯折硅胶、适配牵引绳/推车/自行车,功能更偏通用型而非独特创新
  • 适合遛狗、跑步、骑行时需要临时悬挂已用狗便袋的养宠人群,但人群较泛化
  • Sales
    Avg. price: C$36.43|Latest price: C$14.08|Approx. recent monthly revenue: - (- pcs)|Net profit margin: 38.79%

    These products have successfully captured market share and are profitable. Their design and features are suggested for your investment, based on market competition, saturation, and demand.

    New Brands
    VS
    Old Brands
    2 new brands6 old brands
    2 brands have new listings0 brands have new listings
    2 new listings0 new listings
    0 succeeded
    0 succeeded
    2 failed
    0 failed

    Green indicates better success rate, red indicates poorer success rate. If you are a new brand, focus on the left side; if you are an old brand, focus on the right side.

    New Brands
    Old Brands
    ...

      How much did others invest?

      Collapse
    • #Budget Requirement

      Listing

      结论:不建议进入,这个市场不值得投。 用户预算500,000 CNY表面上能覆盖单个ASIN的前期起步,但市场里可识别的盈利产品占比是0%,新品盈利率也是0%,而且新入场品牌的新品盈利率同样是0%,说明不是“钱不够”,而是这个类目本身几乎没有可复制的赚钱样本。

      Early sourcing + logistics + marketing budget (CAD)
      N/A
      Explains the budget

      With all these investments, who has profitable new releases

      How many new listings are released by old brands?
      0.00%
      New listing success rate (new brands):
      0.00%
      Alternatives
      1. 直接使用带结的普通拾便袋,把已装便便的袋口打结后挂在牵引绳手柄、胸背包 D 环或裤腰扣上,通常不需要额外购买专用夹具;这比专用袋夹更便宜也更容易替代。
      2. 使用一次性垃圾袋夹/钥匙扣小挂钩(如登山扣、S 型扣、迷你钥匙扣)来临时挂载已打结的拾便袋,成本更低、通用性更强,很多人手边就有。
      3. 选择带自带收纳或外挂点的牵引绳/胸背带,把拾便袋直接固定在设备上,减少另购宠物粪便袋夹的必要,属于更一体化的替代方案。
      4. 改用可降解拾便袋 + 便携式小收纳袋组合:把已用袋直接放进小收纳袋或旧纸巾袋中再携带,解决‘手上拿脏袋’的问题,且材料更常见、购买更容易。
      5. 如果只是短距离散步,可采用‘即系即丢’流程:把袋子打结后直接带到最近垃圾桶,不再使用专用袋挂架;这是最省钱、最简单的替代方式。

      Alternative solutions may pose a risk to your investment in certain markets.

    • #Brands Investment Analysis

      Listing

      这个市场不值得进入,直接判定为高风险价格战区。 核心数据很清楚:当前样本里可判断盈利的产品里,盈利率是0%,新上架产品盈利率也是0%;同时两条可量化的样本都是亏损,分别是 Earth Rated 的 B08VN2W5NC(25,589条评论,利润率 -31.8%,月销约1000,月营收约C$6,990)和新品牌 Ulric 的 B0H4V5CJJP(1条评论,利润率 -10.3%,无稳定销量)。这说明不是“能不能打进去”的问题,而是进去后大概率先被成本和平台费用吞掉,不适合大品牌也不适合小品牌。

      从趋势看,市场没有出现健康的新增利润,反而在 2026 年只看到新进入样本持续亏损;按时间线看,2026 年新增新品只有亏损记录,没有可验证的盈利样本。Earth Rated 虽然是老品牌、销量强,但它的代表 ASIN 仍然亏损,说明这个类目已经被高成本+低客单+高履约费用压得很死;Ulric 这种新品牌的首个 ASIN 直接亏损且只有 1 条评论,说明小品牌想靠常规打法切入几乎没有胜算。你要求的“Genuine small business success(<300 reviews/year)”在这份数据里没有出现;相反,样本显示的是两个失败案例,说明这个市场不是给小商家试错的。

      如果你一定要找可对标的对象,能学的只有“不要这样做”:Earth Rated 的 B08VN2W5NC 证明了即便是成熟品牌,也会因为定价过低、FBA 费用过重而亏到 -31.8%;Ulric 的 B0H4V5CJJP 则说明新品牌在 C$9.99 这种价格下,连起步都很难撑住。对你当前 C$500,000 的预算来说,这不是“预算够不够”的问题,而是模型本身不成立:大品牌进来也要重投放和品牌溢价,小品牌进来则需要更激进的打法,但这里没有看到任何能支撑小品牌自然成功的证据。结论很明确:不要进入。

      Ulric
      Least investment in new productsMost investment in new productsNew products with Highest revenue
      Dog Poop Bag Holder 2 Pack, Hands Free Waste Bag Carrier with Metal Clips, Stainless Steel Dog Poop Bag Holder for Leash, Backpack, Key Ring and Dog Walking Accessories
      Recent Monthly Revenue (CAD):-(-)
      B0H4V5CJJP (5/5 (1 Reviews))Brand is a new entry in this market
      New ReleaseInsufficient Sales to Meet MOQUnderperformingNot enough sales volume to meet 100 MOQ
      Earth Rated
      Old brand with the most profitable new products
      Earth Rated Dog Poop Bag Holder, Durable and Guaranteed Leakproof
      Recent Monthly Revenue (CAD):-(-)
      B0D4TMK2WNBrand is an old entry in this market
      Old ReleaseInsufficient Sales to Meet MOQOld ReleaseNot enough sales volume to meet 100 MOQ
      Earth Rated Dog Poop Bag Holder, Durable and Guaranteed Leakproof, Unscented, Dispenser with Starter Roll
      Recent Monthly Revenue (CAD):C$6,990.00(1000pcs/month)
      B08VN2W5NC (4.8/5 (25589 Reviews))Brand is an old entry in this market
      Old ReleaseSufficient Sales to Meet MOQOld ReleaseNet profit margin below 10.00%
    • #Differentiations

      Unique productsCommon products
      Dog Poop Bag Holder 2 Pack, Hands Free Waste Bag Carrier with Metal Clips, Stainless Steel Dog Poop Bag Holder for Leash, Backpack, Key Ring and Dog Walking Accessories
      Differentiation:
      1. 金属夹式造型,和常见圆筒/挂扣款差异大
      2. 主打临时挂放已用便袋,功能直观
      3. 小巧轻便,适合遛狗时解放双手,容易吸引点击
      B0H4V5CJJP (5/5 (1 Reviews))Brand is a new entry in this market
      New ReleaseInsufficient Sales to Meet MOQUnderperformingNot enough sales volume to meet 100 MOQ
      PuppyDoggy Dog Poop Bag Holder for Leash Waste Bag Carrier Dog Poop Bag Dispenser for Walking Running Bicycle Accessory 2 Pieces (Green)
      Differentiation:
      1. 硅胶可弯折结构,外观更醒目
      2. 绿色配色亮眼,图片辨识度高
      3. 可挂牵引绳、推车、自行车,使用场景更丰富
      B09WRDD5RH (4.7/5 (906 Reviews))Brand is an old entry in this market
      Old ReleaseInsufficient Sales to Meet MOQOld ReleaseNot enough sales volume to meet 100 MOQ
    • What net profit margin are others making?

      Collapse
    • #Net Profit Margins: All vs New

      Listing

      这个市场不适合现在进入,结论很明确:新品牌几乎没有成功样本,利润也没有形成可复制的健康区间,属于高风险、偏价格战的市场。 对小品牌来说,这不是“努力一点就能做成”的盘子;对大品牌来说,虽然有资金能力,但也只能硬打资源战,仍然不是值得推进的市场。

      Profitability difficulty
      Unknown - Insufficient New Releases

      All products distribution on different profit levels

      All products profit ratio distribution, including all products. For products with insufficient sales or missing profit ratio data, they will be categorized into other rows. This distribution included products that cannot determine the release date.

      x < -10.0%
      -10.0% <= x < 0.0%
      0.0% <= x < 10.0%
      10.0% <= x < 20.0%
      20.0% <= x < 30.0%
      30.0% <= x < 40.0%
      x >= 40.0%
      other

      New products distribution on different profit levels

      This are the profit ratios of all new products. There are products without sufficient sales, no more than 100pcs in 3 months, or no profit ratio data, or just released. Those will be considered as 'other'

      x < -10.0%
      -10.0% <= x < 0.0%
      0.0% <= x < 10.0%
      10.0% <= x < 20.0%
      20.0% <= x < 30.0%
      30.0% <= x < 40.0%
      x >= 40.0%
      other
    • #Top Products by Net Profit Margin

      Top 20 Non-Profitable Products

      Products with negative profitability ranked by lowest profit value. Only includes products classified as non-profitable regardless of release date.

      B08VN2W5NC
      B08VN2W5NC
      Earth Rated
      2021-03-12
      No
      C$6.99
      1000pcs
      C$6990.0
      -31.8%
      C$-2222.82
      B0924FC5JS
      B0924FC5JS
      Pogi's Pet Supplies
      2021-09-20
      No
      C$4.99
      100pcs
      C$499.0
      -55.71%
      C$-277.99
      B00J44KLZ2
      B00J44KLZ2
      Pogi's Pet Supplies
      2014-09-26
      No
      C$5.04
      100pcs
      C$504.0
      -54.45%
      C$-274.42
      B08Y8RNXNL
      B08Y8RNXNL
      Hilihali
      2021-03-08
      No
      C$8.72
      100pcs
      C$872.0
      5.07%
      C$44.22
      B08Z5XDNM7
      B08Z5XDNM7
      Ubbi
      2021-03-16
      No
      C$9.26
      -pcs
      C$-
      -19.46%
      C$-
      B09WRDD5RH
      B09WRDD5RH
      PuppyDoggy
      2022-03-29
      No
      C$36.43
      -pcs
      C$-
      38.79%
      C$-
      B00VF47LBG
      B00VF47LBG
      EcoJeannie
      2015-03-30
      No
      C$14.08
      -pcs
      C$-
      7.82%
      C$-
      B09WRDMH5R
      B09WRDMH5R
      PuppyDoggy
      2022-03-29
      No
      C$39.2
      -pcs
      C$-
      39.69%
      C$-
      B0H4V5CJJP
      B0H4V5CJJP
      Ulric
      2026-06-11
      No
      C$9.99
      -pcs
      C$-
      -10.33%
      C$-
      B09Y8S5YRN
      B09Y8S5YRN
      PuppyDoggy
      2022-04-19
      No
      C$52.45
      -pcs
      C$-
      42.65%
      C$-
      B0GVDTH1D7
      B0GVDTH1D7
      SLSON
      2026-03-30
      No
      C$7.79
      -pcs
      C$-
      -29.38%
      C$-
      B0D4TMK2WN
      B0D4TMK2WN
      Earth Rated
      2024-05-22
      No
      C$-
      -pcs
      C$-
      -%
      C$-
      B0F1LBCXV3
      B0F1LBCXV3
      Hilihali
      2025-03-16
      No
      C$-
      -pcs
      C$-
      -%
      C$-
      B09ZHTWVSR
      B09ZHTWVSR
      PuppyDoggy
      2022-05-04
      No
      C$-
      -pcs
      C$-
      -%
      C$-
      B073C2X74H
      B073C2X74H
      EcoJeannie
      2017-06-23
      No
      C$-
      -pcs
      C$-
      -%
      C$-
      B07QQRR2Q3
      B07QQRR2Q3
      Pogi's Pet Supplies
      2019-04-15
      No
      C$-
      -pcs
      C$-
      -%
      C$-

      Top 20 Non-Profitable New Products

      New products with negative profitability ranked by lowest profit value. Only includes newly released products classified as non-profitable.

      B0H4V5CJJP
      B0H4V5CJJP
      Ulric
      2026-06-11
      No
      C$9.99
      -pcs
      C$-
      -10.33%
      C$-
      B0GVDTH1D7
      B0GVDTH1D7
      SLSON
      2026-03-30
      No
      C$7.79
      -pcs
      C$-
      -29.38%
      C$-
    • Is this a good time to enter the market?

      Collapse
    • #New Product Success Rates

      Listing

      结论很明确:这个市场不值得进入,且已经呈现出明显的价格战和高饱和特征。 新品牌进入后成功率是0%,新发布产品盈利率也是0%;目前看到的两位新品牌 Ulric 和 SLSON 全部失败,说明不是“还有机会”,而是“几乎没有健康入口”。

      证据很硬:市场里可识别的新品牌只有2个,但新发布产品0个盈利、2个全部亏损,盈利率0.00%;按时间看,2026年3月和6月的新上架都直接亏损。 具体到产品,Ulric 的 B0H4V5CJJP 售价 C$9.99,利润率 -10.3%,只有1条评论、销售不可动;SLSON 的 B0GVDTH1D7 也是新发布但非盈利。更关键的是,市场里真正能持续卖得动的,基本是老品牌:Pogi's Pet Supplies 2014年入场,3个产品全都非盈利但仍占据市场存在感;PuppyDoggy 的 B09WRDD5RH 虽然毛利率看起来有 38.79%,却因为“外观通用、差异化弱、竞争极强”而没有形成可持续优势,说明这个类目不是靠表面高毛利就能赢。还要注意,市场里超过200条评论的老牌产品很多,属于强势既有玩家,不该被当成小商家成功案例。当前样本里没有任何真实小商家成功案例可拿来复制。

      对你来说,结论是:大品牌也不建议进,小商家更不该进。 你有 C$500,000 预算,但这个类目需要的不只是首批铺货和广告费,还可能要额外投入品牌、内容和长期竞争成本;在成功率0%、新品牌全灭、且新品几乎都落在亏损区间的情况下,这笔预算不构成进入优势。建议直接放弃这个类目,除非你能做出完全不同于现有通用款的强创新,否则只会陷入同质化和价格战。

      New products success rate.

      What is the ratio of profitable products

      Profitable (Unidentifiable released date)
      Profitable (Old product)
      Profitable (New product)
      Profitable (New product on old listing)
      New products but non profitable
      No data available

      Nonprofitable new products divide by brands

      What is the ratio of different brands owning all nonprofitable new products

      Ulric
      SLSON
    • #Success Rate by Entry Time

      Listing

      这个市场不适合进入,结论很明确:新品牌几乎没有成功样本,且最近入场全部失败,已经是高风险的同质化价格战市场。 你的预算有50万人民币,看起来足以覆盖单个ASIN前期投入,但这类品类真正的问题不是起步资金,而是缺乏差异化、利润被压薄,继续进场只会更难卖。

      How many products released each year

      Y-axis is product counts. X-axis is time period. For each time period, there are 2 column, each column is a released type of a product. Columns are in following orders: New product, New product on old listing

      How many products released each month

      Y-axis is product counts. X-axis is time period. For each time period, there are 2 column, each column is a released type of a product. Columns are in following orders: New product, New product on old listing

    • #Net Profit Margins by Entry Time

      Different profit ratios of products released in year

      Header is the profit ratios and first column is different time period. Each cells includes how many products are relased at the specific timerange and has a corresponding profit ratios. Only profitable and with active sales (more than 100 pcs in 3 months) will be considered. Any products without sufficient sold units in 3 months will be marked as 'other'.

      Time/Profit%x < -10.0%-10.0% <= x < 0.0%0.0% <= x < 10.0%10.0% <= x < 20.0%20.0% <= x < 30.0%30.0% <= x < 40.0%x >= 40.0%other
      202200000000
      202300000000
      202400000000
      202500000000
      202600000002
      ≥ 10% Profitable
      < 10% Unprofitable
      Unidentifiable

      Different profit ratios of products released in month

      Header is the profit ratios and first column is different time period. Each cells includes how many products are relased at the specific timerange and has a corresponding profit ratios. Only profitable and with active sales (more than 100 pcs in 3 months) will be considered. Any products without sufficient sold units in 3 months will be marked as 'other'.

      Time/Profit%x < -10.0%-10.0% <= x < 0.0%0.0% <= x < 10.0%10.0% <= x < 20.0%20.0% <= x < 30.0%30.0% <= x < 40.0%x >= 40.0%other
      2025/700000000
      2025/800000000
      2025/900000000
      2025/1000000000
      2025/1100000000
      2025/1200000000
      2026/100000000
      2026/200000000
      2026/300000001
      2026/400000000
      2026/500000000
      2026/600000001
      ≥ 10% Profitable
      < 10% Unprofitable
      Unidentifiable
    • What factors contribute to success or failure?

      Collapse
    • #Case Study

      Success Cases
    What is Keble?

    Keble is an e-commerce AI Agent that helps sellers solve daily e-commerce issues. This report is generated by Keble AI.

    Analyze Product Opportunity with Keble
    1. One report to tell you whether to enter the market or not, significantly reducing inventory risk.
    Keble AI Agent